Cruising is a holiday type unlike any other, and one that is loved by many. A once-in-a-lifetime cruising adventure can take you anywhere across the globe, from the coldest locations to some of the world’s warmest climates.
Two of the most popular cruising locations take you to two opposite corners of the globe, Alaska and the Caribbean. Stark contrasts in many ways, these two locations both offer once-in-a-lifetime experiences; from stunning views and unique cultures to wildlife sightings in abundance. But which location is actually better?
In this article, we dive deep into the facts and figures to bring you the answer to that all-important question: Alaska cruises vs Caribbean cruises: Which is better?
Alaska overview
Alaska is now one of the most popular cruise destinations in the world and is known for being pure, raw and humongous in scale.
To put the size of Alaska into perspective, it is home to national parks that are the size of entire nations and is home to glaciers that are bigger than some US states. It is the largest state in the US and is seven times the size of the UK, covering more than 660,000 square miles.
Alaska is also the least densely populated state and its vast stretches of unspoilt landscapes are home to northern lights dancing in the sky, crystal clear lakes, calving glaciers, evergreen rainforests and stunning wildlife.
We spoke to some travel bloggers who have visited Alaska before and James Smith from Only By Land felt the state was home to some of the most beautiful places he has seen.
“Alaska is home to some of the most beautiful places on earth. Many of these are glaciers which are best viewed from the sea. I particularly remember Glacier Bay. In fact, one of the most memorable experiences of my life was viewing the snow-capped mountains and huge glaciers from the emerald-coloured water. What's more, the cruise ship captain rotated the ship so not only could I view it privately from my balcony but so could everybody else on board. The visit to Glacier Bay alone warrants cruising to Alaska.”
Christy from The Ordinary Traveler has been on a cruise to the Caribbean as well as Alaska and for her, there was only one winner.
“ I’ve been on cruises in both destinations and as an outdoor enthusiast, I would have to pick Alaska as my favourite. Alaska is one of the few destinations that I feel a cruise might be a better option for many people than travelling by land. I chose a small boat cruise with plenty of adventure activities — including daily hikes, kayaking, SUP and Zodiac tours. Every morning we woke up to the most breathtaking views like glaciers and mountain scenes that looked like they belonged on a postcard.”
The state is also easily accessible as you can book flights to Canada and travel to Alaska from there as well as from the US.
The Caribbean
The Caribbean is a destination on the wish lists of many and one that offers a whole lot more than just warm and vibrant climates and stunning views everywhere you go. It is a location of immense history, abundant wildlife and exquisite cuisines.
We spoke to a selection of travel bloggers who have visited the Caribbean on a cruise, Ben from Cruise Fever was the first to tell us why he loves the Caribbean:
“ The Caribbean is the ultimate location for cruises. It's perfect for those who want to explore the Caribbean and are afraid of flying. It's easily accessible without getting on an aeroplane. You will visit multiple islands, sample different cultures, explore exotic beaches, and the weather is great year-round.”
The Caribbean is often chosen as a top destination due to its wonderful culture and sense of community, those who visit will feel like they are truly welcome. Laura from Cruise Lifestyle Blog agrees:
“ Overall, the Caribbean is a really good destination for first-time cruisers. A Caribbean cruise is what most people imagine a cruise to be and there are many reasons to choose this type of cruise. Island life seems to make people happy and it's always refreshing to meet friendly locals who want you to enjoy your time on their island. I have fallen in love with destinations like Barbados and St Lucia so much that I want to go back and see more. The beauty of a Caribbean cruise is that the islands are relatively close to one another and therefore you get the chance to visit many places in one trip.”
This article compares a set of factors to work out which location is better and more suited to your cruising type. Using fair data, we have compared a number of qualities that make a great cruising location.
Continue reading to find out which name takes the top spot as the best cruising location.
Alaska culture vs Caribbean culture
Alaska
Alaska is a location rich in ancient culture and cultural traditions. Prior to the arrival of Europeans and the amalgamation of Alaska with America, the indigenous people ruled the lands and their stories and marks are still left around the country to this day.
You may not think that Alaska has any differences from any of its 48 neighbouring states, but throughout the year, the state is home to a selection of wonderful cultural festivals, celebrations and experiences, including native dances, totem pole celebrations and music and art festivals. Even a wander around the state will offer glimpses of these ancient cultures, so keep your eyes peeled.
“For thousands of years, Alaska Native people have preserved their rich traditions and passed this cultural heritage from generation to generation. While the languages and philosophies vary from region to region, many common goals, values and spiritual beliefs weave these Native societies together in the past as well as today.” Travel Alaska reports.
Alaskan cultural highlights:
- Unique native settlements
- Traditional native dances
- Totem pole celebrations
- Traditional music and art festivals
Alaska culture vs Caribbean culture
Caribbean
Culture is a large part of everyday life in the Caribbean and it is common for communities and villages to be very closely knit, meaning everyone knows everyone and families often share food and supplies.
The Caribbean can have a reputation for being a somewhat unsafe place, as Ben from Cruise Fever explains in a little more detail: “The one downside about cruising to the Caribbean is that locals tend to be more aggressive than in other areas, whether they want to sell you an excursion or visit their shop. However, a simple ‘no thank you’ usually solves this problem. However, not every island in the Caribbean is like this.
”A wander around any Caribbean port will introduce you to the way of life on the islands, with a wealth of history and culture for you to explore. Adam from The Cruise Critic agrees that there is a lot more to the Caribbean than just stunning views and sandy beaches:
“The Caribbean is breathtakingly beautiful and exceptionally varied. Most people think of it just as palm-fringed beaches, but there is a wealth of history and culture, which includes historical monuments such as garrisons and colonial architecture, as well as unusual experiences like the world’s only drive-in volcano, on St Lucia.”
A common theme that those who have been on a Caribbean cruise often comment on is the busyness of the ports. It is well worth moving away from the built-up, tourist areas and venturing further afield, as Adam continues: “As Caribbean cruise ports are entirely geared up to the cruise passenger, it’s advisable to look beyond these areas as much as possible. Explore a little if you can - just one street off the main drag can give you a glimpse of the ‘real’ Caribbean. Some areas like Roatan, Jamaica can be dangerous, so avoid exploring the area on your own, and book a cruise ship sponsored tour, if you can, as you will be looked after well.
”Laura from Cruise Lifestyle Blog also agrees that looking to find the less commercialised areas is the best way to explore: “I particularly enjoy visiting the less commercialised ports in the Caribbean as it gives you a real insight into local life. I admire the ingenuity and resourcefulness of the locals. They use what they have, which can be seen in the hand-painted signs, rustic beach bars and local crafts.”
Caribbean cultural highlights:
- Enjoy an afternoon of ‘liming’ or chilling out as it is commonly known
- Explore ancient forts and castles and learn about ancient tribes
- Music and dance carnivals
Which location is better for culture: Alaska
Book your dream cruise to Alaska
Both locations are extremely popular, but out of the factors we looked at Alaska comes out on top.
Learn moreLatest Articles
How to Spend 2 Weeks Exploring Atlantic Canada: The Ultimate Guide
Aimee Levajac
06/11/2024
From Newfoundland's rugged coastlines to the charming streets of Halifax, this guide highlights the must-see attractions, hidden gems, and local experiences across each province in Atlantic Canada.
Best facts about Canada's wilderness
Oliver Moughan
30/10/2024
Uncover fascinating facts about Canada's vast and diverse wilderness, highlighting its unique ecosystems, wildlife, and conservation efforts.
Holland America Line’s Yukon and Denali Cruise: The Ultimate Adventure
Oliver Moughan
24/10/2024
Explore two of North America's most spectacular destinations, the rugged beauty of Canada’s Yukon and the untamed wilderness of Denali in Alaska, with Holland America Line’s Yukon and Denali cruise tours.
The most popular attractions in Ontario
Nick Talbot
23/10/2024
Did you know Ontario, in East Central Canada, is larger than France and Spain combined? Or that the province has over 250,000 lakes - including the Great Lakes bordering the US - which contain a fifth of the planet's fresh water? Ontario is home to some of Canada’s most iconic attractions and exciting cities like Toronto and Canada's capital, Ottawa. From epic natural features to parks and world-famous towers, there’s a little something for everyone in Ontario.